Take a look at some of the local’s favorite spots that showcase their favorite slice of pie, either to-go or for dessert at a restaurant.
Chew Chew isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a Riverside staple, known for its vintage charm and a menu that brings together comfort and creativity. Whether you're in for a perfectly cooked steak, a fresh seafood dish, or an authentic pasta, every meal feels like a special occasion. And when it comes to dessert, their key lime pie is the perfect way to cap it off. The tangy lime filling strikes just the right balance of tart and sweet, in a crisp, buttery graham cracker crust that adds the perfect crunch. Locals swear by it, and once you’ve had a bite, you’ll understand why this pie keeps guests coming back for more.
Click here to learn more.
Priscilla’s Ultimate Soul Food is a family-owned restaurant in Hillside that serves hearty soul food in a cafeteria-style kitchen. The meals are fried, smothered, and sauteed to perfection. From crispy fried chicken and catfish to tangy BBQ ribs and meatloaf, delicious comfort food is always on the menu. And what is more comforting than a piece of pie? At Priscilla’s, no meal is complete without a slice of homemade sweet potato, pecan, or lemon pie. Priscilla’s pies are always the perfect ending to a great meal.
Click here to learn more.
Steak + Vine isn’t just a steakhouse—it’s a place where great food and good company come together over prime cuts, fresh seafood, and expertly mixed bourbon cocktails. The vibe is warm, the service is top-notch, and every meal feels like an occasion. And while the steaks are the star of the show, don’t skip dessert. Their key lime pie is bright and tangy, while the peanut butter pie is pure, creamy indulgence. Whether you’re celebrating something special or just out for a great meal, a slice of pie at Steak + Vine is always the right call.
Pro Tip: Order it topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream that comes from their neighbor Tate's Old Fashioned Ice Cream Shop! It's the best of both worlds.
Click here to learn more.
Although they don’t exactly fit the category, there are a couple of places that need a shout-out when it comes to pie, or kind-of pie, delicious treats.
Take a look:
Broken Tart in Oak Park is a labor of love crafted by two dedicated sisters who believe in making every day extraordinary. From breakfast pastries like flaky scones to expertly crafted lattes, Broken Tart elevates the simple joys of life. While their menu typically showcases handcrafted cakes that are as beautiful as they are delicious, their pies are just as lovely.
So why the honorable mention? They aren't actually a pie shop, but a bakery with a cult following for their occasional, yet absolutely unforgettable, pies. They don’t appear on the menu often, but when they do—especially around holidays like Easter or Thanksgiving—you can bet they sell out fast. If you’re lucky enough to grab one, you’re in for something special. Keep an eye on their website for updates, because when Broken Tart decides to bake a pie, it’s the kind of thing worth planning ahead for.
Click here to learn more.
When it comes to making cookies, Twisted Cookie in Forest Park takes their job very seriously. In addition to delicious, gourmet cookies — like cinnamon roll butter cookies, chocolate chip Nutella stuffed cookies, and half-dipped sea salt chocolate chip cookies — they also make cupcake cookies, cheesecake cookies, cookie bark, and cookie pies. What's a cookie pie, you ask? A dreamy combination of flaky cookie crust with fresh pie fillings and baked to perfection. Whether it’s a pecan pie cookie, an apple pie cookie, or a triple berry pie cookie, you'll experience the incredible flavor of your favorite pie wrapped in a cookie package!
Click here to learn more.
Vesuvio Bakery and Deli has earned a reputation for serving some of the best cannoli this side of the city, with flavors like your traditional cannoli filling and seasonal favorites like pumpkin spice. But the sweet treats don’t stop there—this North Riverside gem also offers a variety of custards, danishes, cookies, and donuts. While traditional pies aren’t on the menu, they’ve got the next best thing: pie bars. All the flavor of a classic pie, packed into a buttery, handheld treat. With flavors rotating daily, you’ll want to get there early to snag your favorite!
Click here to learn more.
After exploring some of the best pie spots in Oak Park and beyond, one thing is certain—this area is a dream for dessert lovers. Whether you’re drawn to the nostalgia of a classic fruit pie, the indulgence of a creamy, decadent slice, or the creativity of something totally unexpected, there’s no shortage of sweet discoveries. So go ahead, grab a fork (or a pie bar), and enjoy every last bite. Happy pie hunting!