The Local Guide to the Best Pie Near Oak Park

If you’re on the hunt for the best pie in the Oak Park Area, you’ve come to the right place. Whether you’re craving a slice of something sweet, a whole pie to impress at your next gathering, or a creative twist on a classic, there’s no shortage of options due west of Chicago.

From perfectly flaky crusts to fillings that taste like nostalgia (or a bold new adventure), we’re rounding up the top pie spots locals can’t stop raving about. So grab a fork—or just go straight in with a bite—and let’s dig in!

If it’s a whole pie you’re looking for, you’re in luck! 

Let’s take a look:

At the Brown Cow Ice Cream Parlor in Forest Park, you’ll find a variety of old-fashioned sweet treats. This charming, vintage ice cream parlor handcrafts super-premium ice cream in-house using local ingredients. But if you’re not in the mood for ice cream, they have incredible pies to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Whether you want to try a sampling of mini pies or prefer a whole delicious pie to share, Brown Cow has you covered with choices like chocolate cream pie, Dutch apple, chocolate peanut butter, and mixed berry pie. And don’t forget to pick up a pint of ice cream on the side!

Click here to learn more. 

Forest Park Bakery is the kind of place that feels like home from the moment you step inside. A true neighborhood staple, this longtime family-owned bakery has been serving up incredible sweets for years, and locals can’t get enough. Whether you're stopping in for their famous donuts, out-of-this-world cookies, or a box of fresh-baked treats to share, you know you’re in for something special.

When it comes to pies, they keep it classic—think cherry, apple, and other seasonal flavors depending on the time of year. No matter what you choose, one thing is certain: Forest Park Bakery knows how to do comfort food right. And with a staff as warm as their pastries, it's no wonder this spot has a loyal following!

Click here to learn more. 

For years, the Happy Apple Pie Shop has been a beloved institution in Oak Park, serving delicious apple pies and spreading joy to the community. Their unique blended work environment brings together individuals with and without intellectual and developmental disabilities to create the most delectable pies.

Every week, the shop features at least three pies, including their signature apple pie, plus two other seasonal flavors available whole, by the slice, or in mini pies. Don't miss out on the Happy Apple Pie Shop's amazing treats – they sell out daily!

Click here to learn more.

Mary's Morning Mixup is more than just a diner—it's a cherished community hub where locals gather to enjoy a hearty, home-cooked meal. From classic omelets bursting with fillings to delicious steak and eggs, Mary's menu offers a wide range of breakfast and lunch options. However, everyone in Brookfield knows that the pies at Mary's steal the spotlight.

Made fresh daily with love and care, these pies have become the stuff of legends among Brookfield residents. Whether craving a slice of warm apple pie with a flaky crust or the creamy richness of a decadent chocolate silk pie, Mary's has something for everyone. So, next time you find yourself in Brookfield, stop by Mary's Morning Mixup for a slice of homemade goodness or even order a whole pie to take home for a special occasion. 

Click here to learn more. 

Oak Park Bakery has been a go-to spot for sweet treats for over 30 years, and it’s easy to see why. This family-owned gem is known for its legendary donuts, beautifully crafted custom cakes, and melt-in-your-mouth coffee cakes that keep locals coming back for more. Need something special for a celebration? They’ll whip up a custom dessert that’s just as delicious as it is picture-perfect.

But let’s talk about their pies—because the selection is nothing short of amazing. From classics like apple and pecan to dreamy banana cream, tangy lemon meringue, and seasonal favorites like pumpkin and strawberry, there’s a pie for every craving. Whether you’re picking up a slice for yourself or a whole pie to share, Oak Park Bakery makes sure every bite is pure perfection.

Click here to learn more. 

Spilt Milk is a testament to the vision and dedication of sisters Molly & Meg Svec in the heart of Oak Park. What began as a humble bakery in 2014 has blossomed into a beloved local gem, drawing patrons from far and wide with its commitment to quality and community. Molly & Meg's passion for supporting local Midwest farms shines through in every bite, as they meticulously source the freshest ingredients to craft their perfect pastries, cookies, breakfast treats, and pies. 

Every pie at Spilt Milk is made with care, using high-quality ingredients that let the flavors shine. The buttery, flaky crust is the perfect complement to every filling, whether it’s the smooth, citrusy bite of key lime or the deep, velvety richness of chocolate cream. Seasonal specialties and rotating flavors mean there’s always something new to try, keeping even the most dedicated pie lovers on their toes. And while the desserts steal the show, the warm, welcoming atmosphere makes every visit feel like a gathering of friends. 

Click here to learn more.