The Best Pepper and Egg Sandwich in Oak Park & the Near West Suburbs

Prepare to embark on a culinary journey through Oak Park and the Near West Suburbs as we delve into the savory delight that is the pepper and egg sandwich. A beloved staple of local cuisine, this mouthwatering creation has captured the hearts and taste buds of residents and visitors alike. Join us as we explore the diverse array of eateries and diners in this vibrant region, each offering its own unique twist on this classic comfort food.


From traditional Italian delis to trendy brunch spots, there's no shortage of options when it comes to finding the perfect pepper and egg sandwich in Oak Park and the surrounding suburbs. So, prepare your appetite and get ready to discover the best of the best in this culinary quest for the ultimate pepper and egg sandwich experience.

20240223_181730 (1)-1



What is a pepper and egg sandwich? 


This one might sound self-explanatory, but let’s dive in. The pepper and egg sandwich is often tied to being an Italian-American classic, specifically popular in Chicago, with a simple yet flavorful combination of ingredients. Traditionally served on a crusty Italian roll or a soft hoagie bun, this hearty sandwich features scrambled eggs infused with sautéed bell peppers and onions, seasoned with a touch of salt, pepper, and perhaps a sprinkle of grated cheese for added richness. 


Bursting with savory goodness and a hint of sweetness from the peppers, the pepper and egg sandwich is a satisfying breakfast or brunch option that has stood the test of time. Its origins can be traced back to Italian immigrants in the early 20th century, who devised this humble yet delicious dish as a hearty and affordable meal option, especially amongst Catholics looking for a vegetarian meal on Fridays during Lent. Over the years, the pepper and egg sandwich has become a cherished comfort food staple, celebrated for its simplicity, versatility, and irresistible flavor profile.


Local’s picks for the best pepper and egg sandwich Near Oak Park


If you're searching for a pepper and egg sandwich near Oak Park, you're in luck. This vibrant area boasts an abundance of eateries and delis serving up their unique takes on this beloved classic, ensuring something to satisfy every craving.


Take a look at the local favorite options. 


Al’s Grill  | Oak Park


Nestled in the heart of Oak Park, Al's Diner has earned a well-deserved reputation as a beloved local joint, drawing in crowds with its cozy atmosphere and delicious comfort food. Among their menu highlights, the pepper and egg sandwich stands out as a visitor favorite, capturing the hearts and appetites of patrons with its irresistible blend of flavors. 


From the perfectly scrambled eggs to the sautéed peppers, each bite is a symphony of flavors that keeps diners coming back for more. But Al's Diner offers more than just exceptional sandwiches; their menu is brimming with an array of mouthwatering dishes to satisfy every craving. Whether you're in the mood for a classic burger, a hearty plate of pancakes, or a satisfying bowl of soup, Al's Diner has you covered. With its friendly service and affordable prices, it's no wonder that Al's Diner has become a beloved fixture in the Oak Park community.


Pro tip: Ask them to top it with feta!

Currently offered daily!

Al’s Address: 1100 Madison St, Oak Park, IL, 60302 

Click here to learn more. 




Bertolli's Pizza | River Forest


Locals can't get enough of the pepper and egg sandwich from Bertolli's in River Forest, and word on the street is that it's essential to top it off with their fresh mozzarella. The combination of fluffy scrambled eggs, sautéed peppers, and the creamy richness of the mozzarella creates a flavor explosion that keeps customers coming back for more. You can even enjoy this delectable sandwich with Italian sausage. 


But Bertolli's isn't just famous for its signature sandwich; this beloved eatery also offers a diverse menu brimming with other options. From classic Italian pasta dishes bursting with robust flavors to crispy thin-crust pizzas piled high with gourmet toppings, there's something for everyone. And let's not forget about their irresistible desserts, including homemade cannoli and tiramisu, guaranteed to satisfy your sweet tooth. With its cozy atmosphere and commitment to quality ingredients, Bertolli's is a favorite dining destination, serving up Italian comfort food at its finest in the heart of River Forest.


Stand out feature: Extra helping of fresh mozzarella. 

Currently offered daily!

Bertolli’s Address: 7973 Lake St, River Forest, IL 60305

Click here to learn more. 



Johnnie’s Beef | Elmwood Park


For those craving a pepper and egg sandwich with a side of nostalgia, look no further than the iconic Johnnie's Beef in Elmwood Park. Renowned for its legendary Italian beef sandwiches, Johnnie's also offers a pepper and egg sandwich that's a local favorite. What sets Johnnie's apart is their willingness to go the extra mile – if you're not abstaining from meat, they'll dip your pepper and egg sandwich in the flavorful beef juice for an extra indulgent experience. 


But the appeal of Johnnie's extends beyond its scrumptious sandwiches; it's a revered landmark and a symbol of culinary excellence in the area. With its bustling atmosphere and no-frills approach to dining, Johnnie's Beef serves up a taste of tradition and community alongside its iconic sandwiches. So, whether you're in the mood for a classic Italian beef or a hearty pepper and egg sandwich, Johnnie's Beef promises a memorable dining experience that's steeped in history and flavor.


Pro tip: Ask for it to be dipped if you’re open to non-vegetarian options. 

Currently offered on Fridays.

Johnnie’s Address: 7500 W North Ave, Elmwood Park, IL 60707

Click here to learn more. 




Massa Cafe | Elmwood Park


Located in Elmwood Park, Massa Cafe elevates the classic pepper and egg sandwich to new heights with their gourmet twist on this beloved Italian-American favorite. Crafted with care and attention to detail, their pepper and egg sandwich features perfectly scrambled eggs, sautéed peppers, and a medley of savory seasonings, all sandwiched between two slices of freshly baked artisan bread. You can even get it as a stromboli! 


But the food at Massa Cafe extends far beyond this sandwich; this local Italian favorite offers a diverse menu brimming with mouthwatering sandwiches, pasta dishes, and more. From classic Italian subs piled high with premium meats and cheeses to hearty pasta plates bursting with rich flavors, there's something to satisfy every palate. And let's not forget about their irresistible gelato, made in-house with the finest ingredients and available in a variety of flavors. With its warm hospitality and commitment to quality cuisine, it's no wonder that Massa Cafe has become a beloved dining destination in the Elmwood Park community, where locals and visitors alike gather to savor the flavors of Italy in every bite.


Pro tip: Don’t leave without a scoop of gelato on the side. 

Currently offered every Friday throughout Lent. 

Massa’s Address: 7434 W North Ave, Elmwood Park, IL 60707

Click here to learn more. 



Parky's Hot Dogs | Forest Park


Nestled in Forest Park, Parky's Hot Dogs is renowned for all of its food, and its delicious pepper and egg sandwich is no exception. Made with a blend of eggs and vibrant green and red peppers, this sandwich boasts a rich and buttery taste that's far from dry, ensuring a satisfying bite every time. But the team at Parky's doesn't stop there—this beloved eatery also serves up some of the best fries in town, perfectly crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, making them the ideal accompaniment to your sandwich. 


In addition to their standout sandwich and fries, Parky's offers a wide variety of other amazing dishes. From classic Chicago-style hot dogs loaded with toppings to juicy burgers cooked to perfection, there's something for everyone to enjoy at Parky's Hot Dogs. With its friendly atmosphere and commitment to quality cuisine, it's no wonder that Parky's has become a favorite dining destination for locals and visitors alike in Forest Park.


Stand out feature: The perfect blend of all ingredients. 

Currently offered daily!

Parky’s Address: 329 S Harlem Ave, Forest Park, IL 60130

Click here to learn more. 



Scudiero’s | Melrose Park


Locals rave about the pepper and egg sandwich from Scudiero's in Melrose Park, and for good reason—the star of the show is undoubtedly the tasty homemade crusty Italian bread it's served on. Each bite is a symphony of flavors and textures, with the perfectly seasoned scrambled eggs and sautéed peppers nestled within the freshly baked bread. 


This charming eatery also offers a variety of other culinary treasures to enjoy. From hearty Italian beef sandwiches dripping with au jus to pasta dishes covered in savory sauces, there's no shortage of delicious options to choose from. And let's not forget their decadent desserts, including creamy tiramisu and rich cannoli, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth. With its cozy ambiance and delectable menu, Scudiero's is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a true taste of Italian comfort food in the heart of Melrose Park.


Stand out feature: Crusty Italian bread and other Lent specials

Currently offered every Friday during Lent. 

Scudiero’s Address: 2113 W Lake St, Melrose Park, IL 60160

Click here to learn more. 


Whether you're enjoying the pepper and egg sandwich just for the season or all year round, Oak Park and the Near West Suburbs offer the best in the area. If you're a resident or just passing through, these locations will surely capture your attention and taste buds as the best places to visit for a delicious pepper and egg delight!